TCCI Scorecard State Election 2021


Release Date: 29/04/2021
The Tasmanian Chamber of Commerce and Industry has today released its state election scorecard.
 
TCCI CEO Michael Bailey said both parties had put forward strong agendas for the community to consider.
 
“Both major parties have committed to supporting the business community and you can see that in their policies,” Mr Bailey said.
 
“The TCCI looks forward to working with the next government to create jobs, grow the economy and support the COVID recovery.”
 
The TCCI ranked policies across a range of issues important to the business community.  The scorecard and commentary on each of the major issues is included below.
 
  Liberal Labor
Taxation C C-
Education B+ B
Workforce C+ C
Economy B C-
Government Contracting B B
Regional Development B B
Transport B- B-
Regulation C C
Digital B TBC
Health and Social C B
Energy B C
 
Taxation: Unfortunately there has been little interest from either party to take on the need for reform of our state taxation system. Labor policies remain silent on taxation and there is only minimal change in the Liberal policies.
 
Education: Both sides have comprehensive approaches to education reform. For business, an effective TAFE is critical and can only be achieved through reform of the structure to ensure that the institution is more focused on the needs of industry.  While Labor has some solid policies in the education policy area, opposing reform to the structure of TAFE (and incorrectly referring to the reform as “privatisation”) is unhelpful.
 
Workforce: Both sides acknowledge the need for better planning and management of our local workforce. Reform of TAFE is linked to this. However, both sides have missed the two major handbrakes on our economic performance as a state: participation and productivity. We see limited policies or strategic initiatives to attempt to address these critical areas.
 
Economy: We have the strongest economy in the nation which has been achieved by solid policy and industry performance. The Liberal plan is to continue to build our way out of COVID including major infrastructure such as Marinus and hydrogen. Two issues that have not been adequately addressed by either side are: how we ensure that the State Budget is sustainable into the future (particularly as the cost of health increases); and how we manage our unfunded government superannuation liability.
 
Government Contracting: Both Labor and the Liberals have signed the TCCI Charter.
 
Regional Development: Both parties have a strong commitment to supporting Tasmania’s regions; including the support for industry sectors that are vital in regional Tasmania such as agriculture, tourism, forestry, and aquaculture.
 
Transport: This remains a key issue for Tasmanian business and citizens. Both parties have a strong focus on road infrastructure through investments in highways and easing congestion. The Liberals also have commitments to invest in port infrastructure. One area that will require focus is ensuring that road and infrastructure commitments are delivered. We note that the Government’s billion dollar infrastructure strategy was less than half executed.
 
Regulation: Neither party specifically addresses further reducing the regulatory burden on Tasmanian business.
 
Digital: The Liberal policy regarding digital inclusion is pleasing and will assist Tasmania’s digital performance. We were unable to find Labor policies relating to digital.
 
Health and Social Services: Labor policies in health deal with the need for greater structural reform in the health system. They also have comprehensive social services policies. However, questions remain about the long-term affordability of Tasmania’s health system.
 
Energy: Liberal policy is comprehensive and includes building infrastructure (such as investments in Marinus and hydrogen). Both parties also offer additional support for renewable energy solutions for business and the wider community.
 
 
Contact: TCCI Chief Executive Officer, Michael Bailey, mobile 0437 322 338
 




Leave message Subscribe



 
 
 Security code